The rusted-out pickup rumbles down Main Street. A girl, all of five and all smiles, rides shotgun. The air is warm, the summer sun bright. The girl leans out the window the way her golden retriever, Lottie, often does. The wind twists and tangles the girl’s long, sandy hair and—
The passenger door flies open. The girl drops to the asphalt and tumbles to a stop.
Faulty door latch.
No seatbelt.
No broken bones!
No stitches!
The girl is lucky to be alive. Had she landed on her head and not the backside of her corduroys, she surely would have died.
Or so the story goes.
The bank teller, the barber, and the barmaid of Main Street will recount it for years to come, along with every eyewitness at Auchenbach’s Laundromat and Vi’s five and dime. Always they will tell the tale in the astonished, reverent tone reserved for the proclamations of miracles—the boy who walked away from the plane crash! the face of Jesus that appeared in a bowl of chowder!
“Happened right in front of the Glen Rose Tavern. Never seen old Scotty so torn up,” the bank teller said.
“That poor man! The way he carried on you’da thought his little girl had died after all,” the barber said.
“I’ve never seen a grown man cry like that. He was just a sobbin’ and a sobbin’ as he held her. And his little one? Not a single tear,” the barmaid said.
Six years old. Seven years old. Eight. Then nine.
The girl has come to cherish the story despite a diminished interest in herself as its protagonist. The truck’s driver is the character of her fascination. She has elevated her gentle father to hero status, despite her mother’s increasingly frequent and increasingly furious objections.
Ten years old. Eleven years old. Twelve. Then thirteen.
The story of the girl has changed as narratives do with time and retelling. That she survived, that she is a miracle, this part remains the same. (Unless the girl’s mother, a chronically unreliable narrator, tells the story.) The girl listens close, always, to the bank teller, the barber, the barmaid. She must bite her tongue to keep from interjecting, Tell me again how he sobbed as he held me! Had her story been recorded on a cassette tape, she’d have worn this part thin. She has never, to her recollection, seen her hero cry.
Nineteen.
The girl, now a young woman, has become the storyteller. Chasing lemon drop shots with ice-cold cheap beer, she holds forth at the college bar on Friday nights. A practiced raconteur, her version of her fall is comical. (She has honed a habit of costuming anecdotes from her childhood in humor.) It was the 70s! Who wore seatbelts back then? By this time the woman knows she’s not special, so she omits the bit about the miracle. She also omits how the grown man had cried when he held her. The passing of time has rendered this detail too precious to share. She saw him cry once when she was fifteen. It had terrified her and made her hate her mother more. Her hero had fallen.
Twenty-one.
The woman returns to Main Street, summoned home by a 3 a.m. call from her mother. All around the woman disembodied faces bob on a sea of black fabric. Behind them a supine and stony replica of her father anchors a bed of pale blue satin. The barmaid, now a waitress at the local diner, totters through the crowd and tentatively approaches the woman. The barmaid (the characters in the woman’s script are immutable) smooths invisible wrinkles from her black dress and hugs the woman. The woman hears the words “I’m so sorry” for the millionth time and bites her cheek to keep from screaming. Does she remember that day, the barmaid asks the woman when their hug breaks apart, the day she fell out of her daddy’s truck? The barmaid points in the direction of the door, in the direction of Main Street. (The event occurred directly across from the funeral home, a detail that until now had never seemed relevant to the woman’s story.) The woman nods. She’s come to understand that her memory is only a collage crafted from other people’s memories, a distinction that doesn’t trouble her. The woman listens, rapt, while the barmaid unspools her version of the event. The barmaid omits nothing.
“To this day, I’ve never seen a grown man cry the way your daddy did when he held you,” the barmaid says.
Fresh tears bloom in the woman’s eyes. She looks past the barmaid and out across the black sea to her father cast in stone, her hero again and irrevocably for all time.
R.L. Marstellar is a writer and live storyteller. Her career path is a circuitous one: structural engineer—marketing specialist—finance hack—personal chef—entrepreneur. Writing is the one endeavor she has faithfully pursued. Her work has appeared in Under the Gum Tree, Midway Journal, and Evening Street Review and earned Bacopa Literary Review’s 2018 prize for creative nonfiction. She is currently working on a novel based on her experience hiking the Appalachian Trail. When she’s not writing about bad mothers and the minefields of middle age, you’ll find her at a Chicago dive bar open mic channeling her inner rockstar.
